Lost in the storytelling syrup


Hey Reader,

Yesterday, I stopped at a new coffee shop in a trendy neighborhood.

Me: I’ll take a cold brew. Oat milk. One packet of Splenda.
Barista: We don’t have sugar.

Me: You... don't have sugar?
Barista: We have syrups.

She pointed to a little sign—

Vanilla.
Salted maple.
Cherry.
Spiced rosemary.

🤯

Just as I was about to flee this artisanal nightmare, my coffee date walked in.

In case you’re wondering—I ordered it black.

Maybe I’m the first weirdo to ask for sugar in my coffee.

Or maybe... they've spent so much time surrounded by fancy schmancy syrups that they forgot how strange it sounded to someone walking in for the first time.

"Wait... you don't have sugar?"

Trial lawyers can fall into the same trap.

When you've lived with a case long enough, the things that should make you stop and say "Wait... what?" start to feel ordinary.

Steve and I were talking with one of our clients this week.

We meet with her twice a month to strategize on her cases.

As we were wrapping up an hour of discussing witnesses, timelines, and strategy, she casually said:

"Oh yeah... my client's sister said..."

(A case detail that immediately changed the direction of the conversation.)

Steve and I stopped.

"Wait. Why are we just hearing this now?"

To the attorney: It was another detail in a case she'd been living with for weeks.

To us: It was the first thing we'd have written on the whiteboard pointing toward reasonable doubt.

It’s why we looove strategy sessions.

Especially when we heard this from the attorney afterwards:

“This is the kind of prep that wins trials.”

She hadn't forgotten the fact.
She'd forgotten it was surprising.

Our storytelling Spidey-senses zone in on the facts that have become ordinary to you—but won't be ordinary to a juror.

And sometimes the breakthrough isn't finding new evidence.

It's finally hearing the evidence you've had all along.

Schedule a free 30-minute strategy session and we’ll help you pressure test your case on the spot.

You might already have your "Wait... what?" moment.

Let's find it together… the sooner the better!

→ [Schedule HERE]​

Your sweetener-loving trial consultants,

PS. I'll probably return to that hipster cafe. Still thinking about their blueberry scone. I’ll just bring my own Splenda.

PPS. Every case has a "Wait... what?" moment. Click HERE to find yours.


Looking for more resources to help you ‘be you’ AND win more cases?
​
​
​
Start here for more resources and other trainings:​
​
​
💡Turn Facts to Feels: Access Your Jury’s Decision-Making Emotions (Get it here)
​
​
💡Lawyer to Client Jackpot Questions (Get it here)
​
​
💡Cross Lab Podcast: Live simulations putting cross strategies to the test (Listen here)
​
​
💡Acting for Trial Lawyers: Natural, Engaging and Credible Presentations
(Grab it here)
​
​
💡Book a free 30-min strategy session with Steve and Olivia: Pick our brain about your case narrative or witness— no strings attached! (Schedule here)
​

​Trial Haus Consulting​
(657) 464-3117
​Steve@trialhaus.com ​

This email was sent to Reader. You received this email because you are registered with Trial Haus Consulting

​
​Unsubscribe​

© 2025 Trial Haus Consulting

Trial Haus Consulting

Courtroom strategy meets storytelling craft. Weekly insights on deposition prep, cross-examination, and attorney performance — from trial consultants who've trained litigators across 2,000+ depositions.

Read more from Trial Haus Consulting

Hey Reader, [No spoilers in this email. Promise.] Thank God the theater was empty! 90 min. in, Steve and I looked at each other and yelled “What the FU%&?!” We were watching You Can See Everything. The Elizabeth Holmes doc that started filming 34 days before her prison sentence began. If you know Nathan Fielder’s work, especially The Rehearsal, you know his secret weapon… He brings in actors to investigate.Play real people.And realistically rehearse conversations before they happen. It’s all...

Hey Reader, Steve and I managed to pull off a date night on Monday. Given the kids’ gymnastics, parkour, and the logistics of finding a sitter, this deserves its own little celebration. We were STOKED. Seafood tacos here we come! I made reservations at a new restaurant in Little Italy. We arrived, checked in with the host, got a menu, and were shown to our sweet little sidewalk table. We sat down. Got comfortable. They poured us water while we opened our menus. Then, like it was a perfectly...

Hey Reader, Jeff Probst effed up on live TV. Don’t worry—no spoilers—I’m talking about last season’s Survivor 50 finale. (If you’re a Survivor fan and haven’t seen that yet, what have you been doing!?!) Before the winner was revealed, Jeff accidentally sent a contestant packing before the audience saw him lose the fire-making challenge. Jeff could’ve blamed the control room.Over-explained the production mix-up.Pretended it didn’t happen. Instead, he came back from commercial break and said,...